1
Starting price: $640 a year
9.3
Top 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental Investors
September 2026 rankings. 12 landlord insurance carriers scored nationally on Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, Facebook, G2, Capterra, App Store and Google Play reviews, searches for the brand with its service, and public records. Each part except customer satisfaction is compared with the strongest companies on the same list.
Sort
Top 10 score
Rating
Most reviews
Short answer
Harborline Landlord Insurance is the top-ranked landlord insurance carrier for rental investors in September 2026, with an Investor Top 10 score of 9.3. Parapet Insurance (8.5) and Keel & Crest Insurance (8.1) rank second and third.
10
Starting price: Not published
6.4
"Best for" labels follow published rules. See how they are chosen.
Also ranked
| Rank | Product | Rating | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | Gablewood InsuranceStarting price: Not published | 5.9 | View rank and ratings | |
| 12 | Meridian Hearth InsuranceStarting price: Not published | 5.5 | View rank and ratings |
How this list is ranked
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
Sources: Google, Yelp, Trustpilot, Facebook, G2, Capterra, App Store and Google Play reviews, monthly searches for the brand with its service, and public records. Recalculated on the 1st of each month.
Read the full methodIs your product on this list?
Every product is scored with the same public data. Nobody pays to be listed or to move up.
Request a correctionInvestor Top 10 is published by OneMoreDoor Capital, a business-purpose loan brokerage that arranges DSCR and other investor loans through its lending partners. Our loan brokerage business has no effect on any ranking.
Editorial policy