Lodestar Property Insurance: Rank, Score and Ratings
Quotes and binds landlord policies online, including for LLC owners.
Investor Top 10 score#4 of 12
8.0/ 10
Based on 2,500 reviews on 2 sitesCustomer satisfaction7.3
Investor fit8.0
Market presence9.1
Review volume and activity8.7
Transparency and trust7.2
How the score was built
Customer satisfaction (30%)7.34.5 on Trustpilot (1,700), 4.3 on App Store (800)
Investor fit (25%)8.02 of 5 checklist items met
Market presence (20%)9.1About 3,600 counted searches a month, from 1 search phrase
Review volume and activity (15%)8.72,500 reviews, 550 in the last 12 months
Transparency and trust (10%)7.2Publishes its fees, Years in business
Platforms used
Based on 2,500 reviews on 2 sites
- Trustpilot4.5 from 1,700 reviewscounts in full
- App Store4.3 from 800 reviewseach review counts 0.4
Checklist items met
- Insures LLC-owned rentalsInvestor fit
- Quotes onlineInvestor fit
- Publishes its fees or pricingTransparency and trust
- Years in businessTransparency and trust
Ratings by platform
- Trustpilot
- 4.5 1,700 ratings
- App Store
- 4.3 800 ratings
Plans and prices
- Landlord policy
- $610 a year
Plans and prices from Lodestar Property Insurance's website, checked Sep 1, 2026.
What it does and who it fits
- What it does
- Quotes and binds landlord policies online, including for LLC owners.
- Who it fits
- Investors buying across several states.
- Offers
- Online quote, LLC-owned rentals
From Lodestar Property Insurance's website.
Compare Lodestar Property Insurance
Every product on the list, scored the same way.
See the alternativesTop 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental InvestorsInvestor Top 10 is published by OneMoreDoor Capital, a business-purpose loan brokerage that arranges DSCR and other investor loans through its lending partners. Our loan brokerage business has no effect on any ranking.
Editorial policy