Skip to content
Investor Top 10
Claim your listingGet matched
Local pros
Property ManagersRun your rentals day to dayInvestor-Friendly Real Estate AgentsBuy the right propertyShort-Term Rental ManagersRun furnished and nightly rentalsEviction & Landlord AttorneysEvictions, leases and disputesHome InspectorsKnow what you are buyingSoonProperty Tax Appeal FirmsLower your property tax billSoon
View all local pros (14)
Tools and national services
Tenant ScreeningCheck applicants before you signRental Property SoftwareCollect rent and track costsLandlord Insurance CarriersCover your rentalsDeal Analysis ToolsRun the numbers on a dealSoonLandlord Banking & BookkeepingKeep rental money separateSoon1031 Exchange IntermediariesDefer tax when you sellSoon
View all tools and services (15)
Atlanta lists are liveAtlanta, GA
  • Property Managers
  • Investor-Friendly Real Estate Agents
  • Short-Term Rental Managers
  • Eviction & Landlord Attorneys
Open the Atlanta hub
Not sure who to pick? Get matched
Live
City hub, 4 lists liveAtlanta, GAProperty Managers · Investor-Friendly Real Estate Agents · Short-Term Rental Managers · Eviction & Landlord Attorneys
Coming next
Houston, TXSoonDallas–Fort Worth, TXSoonTampa, FLSoonIndianapolis, INSoonCleveland, OHSoonCharlotte, NCSoon
View all cities

Cobalt Shield Insurance: Rank, Score and Ratings

Sells landlord and short-term rental policies online in minutes.

See the alternativesOfficial website
Investor Top 10 score#7 of 12
7.6/ 10
Based on 2,550 reviews on 3 sites
Customer satisfaction5.1
Investor fit8.0
Market presence8.6
Review volume and activity9.1
Transparency and trust9.6
See the full top 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental Investors

How the score was built

Customer satisfaction (30%)
5.14 on Trustpilot (1,500), 4.1 on App Store (600), 3.9 on Google Play (450)
Investor fit (25%)
8.02 of 5 checklist items met
Market presence (20%)
8.6About 2,400 counted searches a month, from 1 search phrase
Review volume and activity (15%)
9.12,550 reviews, 1,275 in the last 12 months
Transparency and trust (10%)
9.6Publishes its fees, Years in business, BBB accredited or A- or better

Platforms used

Based on 2,550 reviews on 3 sites

  • Trustpilot4 from 1,500 reviewscounts in full
  • App Store4.1 from 600 reviewseach review counts 0.4
  • Google Play3.9 from 450 reviewseach review counts 0.4

Checklist items met

  • Covers short-term rentalsInvestor fit
  • Quotes onlineInvestor fit
  • Publishes its fees or pricingTransparency and trust
  • Years in businessTransparency and trust
  • BBB accredited or rated A- or betterTransparency and trust

Ratings by platform

Trustpilot
4.0 1,500 ratings
App Store
4.1 600 ratings
Google Play
3.9 450 ratings

Plans and prices

Landlord
$680 a year

Plans and prices from Cobalt Shield Insurance's website, checked Sep 1, 2026.

What it does and who it fits

What it does
Sells landlord and short-term rental policies online in minutes.
Who it fits
Hosts who want a policy the same day.
Offers
Online quote, Short-term rentals

From Cobalt Shield Insurance's website.

Compare Cobalt Shield Insurance

Every product on the list, scored the same way.

See the alternativesTop 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental Investors

Investor Top 10 is published by OneMoreDoor Capital, a business-purpose loan brokerage that arranges DSCR and other investor loans through its lending partners. Our loan brokerage business has no effect on any ranking.

Editorial policy