Best Cobalt Shield Insurance Alternatives

Investor Top 10 ranks 11 other landlord insurance carriers for rental investors. The highest-scoring alternative to Cobalt Shield Insurance is Harborline Landlord Insurance, at 9.3; Cobalt Shield Insurance itself ranks #7 with 7.6.

Harborline Landlord Insurance

Best overall

Based on 13,400 reviews on 4 sites

Starting price$640a year

9.3

Parapet Insurance

Best for loss-of-rent coverage

Based on 1,100 reviews on 1 site

Starting price$720a year

8.5

Keel & Crest Insurance

Best for short-term rentals

Based on 7,100 reviews on 4 sites

Starting price$590a year

8.1

Lodestar Property Insurance

Based on 2,500 reviews on 2 sites

Starting price$610a year

8.0

Sentinel Oak Mutual

Based on 3,800 reviews on 1 site

Starting priceNot published

8.0

Tidewater Rental Cover

Best for vacant properties

Based on 900 reviews on 1 site

Starting price$560a year

7.8

Ironbark Mutual

Based on 720 reviews on 2 sites

Starting priceNot published

7.3

Fieldstone Landlord Cover

Based on 930 reviews on 2 sites

Starting price$540a year

6.6

Northgate Dwelling Mutual

Based on 4,950 reviews on 2 sites

Starting priceNot published

6.4

Gablewood Insurance

Based on 4,350 reviews on 2 sites

Starting priceNot published

5.9

Meridian Hearth Insurance

Based on 390 reviews on 1 site

Starting priceNot published

5.5

Ranks are from the full list. Top 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental Investors · Cobalt Shield Insurance: rank and ratings

Investor Top 10 is published by OneMoreDoor Capital, a business-purpose loan brokerage that arranges DSCR and other investor loans through its lending partners. Our loan brokerage business has no effect on any ranking.

Editorial policy