Best for short-term rentals
Keel & Crest Insurance: Rank, Score and Ratings
Offers landlord and short-term rental policies bought online.
Investor Top 10 score#3 of 12
8.1/ 10
Based on 7,100 reviews on 4 sitesCustomer satisfaction6.1
Investor fit8.0
Market presence9.8
Review volume and activity10.0
Transparency and trust8.1
How the score was built
Customer satisfaction (30%)6.14 on Google (1,300), 4.2 on Trustpilot (2,600), 4.5 on App Store (1,900), 4.2 on Google Play (1,300)
Investor fit (25%)8.02 of 5 checklist items met
Market presence (20%)9.8About 6,600 counted searches a month, from 1 search phrase
Review volume and activity (15%)10.07,100 reviews, 2,088 in the last 12 months
Transparency and trust (10%)8.1Publishes its fees, Years in business
Platforms used
Based on 7,100 reviews on 4 sites
- Google4 from 1,300 reviewseach review counts 0.5
- Trustpilot4.2 from 2,600 reviewscounts in full
- App Store4.5 from 1,900 reviewseach review counts 0.4
- Google Play4.2 from 1,300 reviewseach review counts 0.4
Checklist items met
- Covers short-term rentalsInvestor fit
- Quotes onlineInvestor fit
- Publishes its fees or pricingTransparency and trust
- Years in businessTransparency and trust
Ratings by platform
- 4.0 1,300 ratings
- Trustpilot
- 4.2 2,600 ratings
- App Store
- 4.5 1,900 ratings
- Google Play
- 4.2 1,300 ratings
Plans and prices
- Landlord
- $590 a year
- Short-term rental
- $1,100 a year
Plans and prices from Keel & Crest Insurance's website, checked Sep 1, 2026.
What it does and who it fits
- What it does
- Offers landlord and short-term rental policies bought online.
- Who it fits
- Owners who rent both long-term and short-term.
- Offers
- Online quote, Short-term rentals
From Keel & Crest Insurance's website.
Compare Keel & Crest Insurance
Every product on the list, scored the same way.
See the alternativesTop 10 Landlord Insurance Carriers for Rental InvestorsInvestor Top 10 is published by OneMoreDoor Capital, a business-purpose loan brokerage that arranges DSCR and other investor loans through its lending partners. Our loan brokerage business has no effect on any ranking.
Editorial policy