Compass Property Management LLC
At a glance
Sources- Rental types
- Condos and townhomes, Single-family
- Out-of-state owners
- Yes
- Owner portal
- Yes
- Broker license
- Not published by the company Is this your company? Add it.
Compass Property Management LLC scores 5.3 out of 10
Sources#21 of 44 ranked property managers in Indianapolis. Five parts, weighted the same for every investor-friendly property manager on this list. Data as of November 1, 2026.
Customer satisfaction30% of the score. Indianapolis average 4.42.9
Star ratings from every review site, trusted more as reviews add up. Scored on the star scale, not compared.
The 3.4 next to the name counts every review once. How we rank
Investor fit25% of the score. Indianapolis average 5.68.0
How much public evidence shows the company serves rental investors, compared with the strongest on this list.
- Manages single-family or 2–4 unit rentals (2 of 2) (met)
- Supports owners who live out of state (1.5 of 1.5) (met)
- Owner portal with monthly statements (1 of 1) (met)
- Investor tools or services (rent analysis, rent-versus-sell, acquisition help, rehab coordination) (1.5 of 1.5) (met)
- Portfolio or multi-door pricing (not met)
- Share of reviews written by owners, not tenants (not met)
6 of 10 checklist points. Full marks on this list start at 7.5 points, so 8.0. See the property manager checklist
Market presence20% of the score. Indianapolis average 5.36.7
How many people search for the company by name to hire it, such as its name with the city or the service, compared with the most-searched on this list. Searches from tenants and job seekers do not count.
Searches counted: compass property management indianapolis (20); 20 a month in all. Full marks on this list start at 90 a month, so 6.7.
Review volume and activity15% of the score. Indianapolis average 6.85.6
How many reviews the company has and how many are recent, compared with the most-reviewed on this list.
55 reviews, 7 in the last 12 months. Full marks on this list start at 669 reviews and 75 in the last 12 months, so 5.6. Most recent: Aug 9.
Transparency and trust10% of the score. Indianapolis average 4.12.0
Published fees, an active license, years in business and memberships, compared with the most transparent on this list.
- Publishes its fees or pricing (not met)
- License checked on the state's own lookup (not met)
- Years in business (not met)
- BBB accredited or rated A- or better (met)
- A professional designation or membership confirmed in the organization's directory (not met)
1 of 10 points. Full marks on this list start at 5 points, so 2.0.
✓ counts toward the score · ○ not found at a public source yet
The same method ranks every company on Investor Top 10. Read how we rank. Nobody pays to be listed or to move up, and claiming a profile never changes a score.
What reviewers say about Compass Property Management LLC
Ratings by site
Read from Google search results and each site. We read reviews to measure them; we never republish them.
What reviews show
SourcesOwners mention most
Licenses, BBB and memberships
Each one is checked against the organization's own public record. What a company only says about itself is shown, never scored.
Fees
Indianapolis's top 10 charge 9% to 10% of rent.
What Compass Property Management LLC handles
Sources- Leasing and rent collection
- Owner portal with monthly statements
- Help buying your next rental
What would your Indianapolis rental earn with Compass Property Management LLC?
Free calculators from OneMoreDoor Capital. Each opens beside the page.
Where Compass Property Management LLC works
SourcesOther areas
Questions about Compass Property Management LLC
Answered by Investor Top 10 from the data on this page, updated monthly.
Is Compass Property Management LLC a good investor-friendly property manager in Indianapolis?
Compass Property Management LLC ranks #21 of 44 on Investor Top 10's November 2026 list of property managers in Indianapolis, with a score of 5.3 out of 10 and a 3.4 rating across 55 reviews on one site.
Does Compass Property Management LLC work with out-of-state owners?
Yes. Compass Property Management LLC lists out-of-state owners as a specialty.
How was this score calculated?
From five parts: customer satisfaction, investor fit, market presence, review volume and activity, and transparency and trust, all from public evidence. The Score tab shows each part and its sources.
Compare with other Indianapolis property managers
See the full top 10Where each fact comes from
Every fact on this profile, and where we read it.
At a glance
- Rental types
- Condos and townhomes, Single-familycompass-property.com · read Sep 26, 2026
- Out-of-state owners
- Yescompass-property.com · read Sep 26, 2026
- Owner portal
- Yescompass-property.com · read Sep 25, 2026
Online owners portal with 24/7 access
What Compass Property Management LLC handles
- Leasing and rent collection
- compass-property.com · read Sep 26, 2026
- Owner portal with monthly statements
- compass-property.com · read Sep 25, 2026
Online owners portal with 24/7 access
- Help buying your next rental
- compass-property.com · read Sep 25, 2026
Compass Property Management LLC is a premier Property Management Company based in Indianapolis area for Buying, Renting and Selling real-estate.
Where Compass Property Management LLC works
- Areas
- Indianapolis, Greenwood, Indy Metro area, central Indianacompass-property.com · read Sep 25, 2026
Compass Property Management LLC has a combined 10+ years of experience in property management in Indianapolis, Greenwood and throughout the Indy Metro area.
What reviews show
- reviews in the last 12 months
- 7Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
- most recent review
- Aug 9Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
- written by owners, not tenants
- 0%Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
- maintenance
- 3Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
- professionalism
- 1Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
- tenant placement
- 1Counted from 55 reviews we read on Google
Score
- Searches counted
- compass property management indianapolis (20)Monthly searches for the name · How we measure
Contact
- Phone
- 8449667368Google Business Profile
- Website
- compass-property.comGoogle Business Profile
- Office
- 4040 S Meridian St Ste 19, Indianapolis, IN 46217Google Business Profile
